View Full Version : How do you discuss literature?
vlshort
04-13-2009, 11:49 PM
My ds is beginning 6/7th grade. So far I haven't "discussed" what he reads with him. We read and discuss history or science. Well, I should say I ask him for facts. I really don't know how to "discuss". I've read a little on the Socratic method of asking questions. I kind of get that, but I don't know what KIND of questions to ask. Besides using guides, like the Progeny guides, can you give me tips on what types of questions or topics/points you discuss about their literature? Any guidance is greatly appreciated!
-vanessa
Have you considered Teaching the Classics by Adam Andrews?
http://www.centerforlit.com/
I really like this resource. It has a DVD for the parent to watch, and some guidelines for discussion.
Lori
Targhee
04-14-2009, 12:57 AM
Have you looked at Deconstructing Penguins? I don't have it personally, but it sounds like a fit for your situation. We're currently just building a dialog relationship with my 1st grader (what did you like about the story, what did you think of what ___ did, was there a part with good description, etc type questions). I'm looking forward to OP answers so I can be ready when the time comes.
Debbie in OR
04-14-2009, 01:10 AM
I can not recommend highly enough a little flip chart called "Quick Flip Questions for Critical Thinking" by Edupress (www.edupressinc.com (http://www.edupressinc.com)). It is just that: a little hand-held flip chart with 6 levels of questions on it.
Level I- Knowledge
Level II- Comprehension
Level III - Application
Level IV- Analysis
Level V - Synthesis
Level VI- Evaluation
You decide what your goal is with the line of questioning ("Do I want to know if they have comprehended the material? Do I want them to apply the material? Do I want them to evaluate the material?" etc...). Then you flip to that section and there is a list of questions to ask to facilitate the discussion.
It's so great...I bought two and keep one in the schoolroom and one in the study because we use them all the time. It has freed me up to get the most out of our discussions. HTH
alegnab
04-14-2009, 06:19 AM
I also recommend Teaching the Classics from Center for Lit. It has pages of questions to ask. It can be used with any book. If you still think you need help using that method after watching the DVD and reading the guide, you can download a book-specific guide to help you through it. The guide for The Bronze Bow is free.
vlshort
04-14-2009, 08:01 AM
These are some great resources! In particular, I'm interested in Teaching the Classics. I think I'll watch to buy the course, maybe used!
-vanessa
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.