Which Logic for next year?

[Hoggirl]

Ds has done The Fallacy Detective and Art of Argument. We did part of The Thinking Toolbox but found it a bit dull. Would you continue on with CAP's next argument course (ack! I cannot recall the name now) or use Memoria Press Traditional Logic with DVDs.

And could you tell me why you would choose what you would choose? I am considering using The Lost Tools of Writing next year and wondered if either would "fit" better with this writing program.

TIA!

[kloumc]

In our homeschooling co-op, we have the 7th graders do Art of Argument & Fallacy Detective. The 8th grade year we use Logic I: Tools for Thinking by Norman Birkett (ClassicalLegacyPress.com) In the 9th grade we use Introductory and Intermediate Logic by Nance/Wilson. This progression has worked really well for several years now.