Cultural Atlas for Young People - Middle Ages OR Penguin Atlas of Medieval History?

[Hoggirl]

Which would you choose and why? Biblioplan suggests Cultural Atlas but Greenleaf suggests Penguin.
Thanks!

[Julie in GA]

My Greenleaf suggests Cultural, and we love it. However, if they've revised the guides, maybe they know something we don't. Can you look inside Penguin on Amazon? Maybe there are more maps, or....

[8FillTheHeart]

I don't own them for the MA, but I do own them for the Ancients. Definitely the Cultural for Young People. The atlases are written on a much higher level (it's been a few yrs since I looked at them, but I am thinking they are more appropriate for late middle/high school.) The Cultural was fine for elementary grades.

[Mrs. Readsalot]

I thinkit is easy to follow, has cool maps, and is very user friendly.

[Hoggirl]

nt