GWG vs FLL

[mo2]

Compare, contrast...tell me which one I want, LOL. I'm stuck. Are they both secular? Is either one of them more "fun" than the other? Both appropriate for a 6yo beginning reader?

TIA.

[Sue G in PA]

Basic difference: FLL is mostly oral. GWG is a workbook program (at least level 4 is!). As for fun...I'm not sure I'd describe either as "fun", but that's just me! LOL! Some parts of FLL I really enjoy as do my ds's. Some parts are too repetitive and boring. GWG is just workbook so if your dc likes that format...he/she would enjoy GWG. I bought FLL and figured I had to use it to get my money's worth, LOL! But, now, I just pick and choose lessons. I didn't want to spend the money on GWG 1/2 so I figured I'd just start formal grammar in grade 3.

[momtolgd]

We tried FLL and it just didn't work for us. DS really likes workbooks...I gave GWG a try and we really like it a lot! It is pretty gentle and doesn't take long to do. DS seems to retain it well also.

[one l michele]

GWG 2 and FLL 2 with my oldest this year and will continue with FLL for my next two. GWG for us was simply going through the grammar motions, ds would skim the top, look at the example, use it as a guide to do the worksheet, and breeze through it without understanding it. He loved it as it took minimal effort. In order for GWG to work one would need to teach the top portion, quiz their dc, then send them off to do the worksheet, not let their dc do the worksheet themselves, even better would be to take away the top portion while they do the exercises :)

FLL is definitely more interactive.

[coffeegal]

I've used FLL 1/2, FLL 3, and GWG 5. FLL 1/2 lays a wonderful foundation for grammar. It is used orally, but does have recommended copywork and dictation exercises. FLL 3 includes a scripted TM and a workbook for the student. I'm currently using FLL 3 with a 3rd and a 4th grader and we're enjoying it greatly. GWG has an extremely well written instruction book that is written for the student to read, a student workbook, and an answer key. My 5th grader has been completing GWG independently and thriving. Both FLL and GWG are excellent programs but my 3rd & 4th graders will be switching to GWG next year for the simple reason that it is more independent and therefore more likely to be done. :rolleyes: