Reason For Science or Supercharged Science?

[Karen in WA]

Anyone use either of these? I am looking for a science to use with my dd, who will be 8th grade. We were able to look at Supercharged Science at the homeschool convention. I had hoped to talk with the author, but she was always busy. I like the looks of both of these programs, but am hoping to hear from someone who has actually used them.
Thanks,
Karen in WA

[Sharon]

Hello,

I was searching the forum for info on supercharged science and came across your post. Do you mind telling me which one you decided to use and your thoughts on it? Thanks so much,
Sharon