What to use for HS grammar

[hsmomto5]

I have always used Abeka for grammar. It is not really a good fit for my 15 yo ds. Any suggestions?
Lora in NC

[CynthiaOK]

There are several other programs used frequently:

Analytical Grammar
Our Mother Tongue (probably more junior high level)
Easy Grammar Plus
and others

What level of ABeka has he completed? Did he do well?

[StaceyinLA]

11th grader doing Analytical Grammar (she loves it and does great with it - she probably doesn't NEED to still be doing grammar, but I like keeping it up just for knowledge's sake)

9th grader going from the AG to EG Plus. She has less attention to detail and is having trouble labeling ALL sentence parts, so I think EG will work great for her.

7th grade ds doing Rod & Staff. He was doing the AG with the others but told me that R&S was his favorite so I am putting him back in it. I figure why try to keep them all in one program that doesn't work for all of them. I think R&S has the BEST of all grammar programs anyway, so I figure he'll be better off in the long run...