Piano programs...any experience?

[yslek]

I posted this on another forum, but received no replies, so I'm trying my luck here...

I was wondering about:

Kinderbach

and

Mrs. Stewart's Piano lessons

I realize that these are geared for different age ranges. I looked at the Kinderbach sample online; my 4yo dd loved it, but the boys (9 & almost 8) thought it was kind of dumb (although the 7yo kept watching!)

Has anyone here used either of these? Any comments?

TIA:)
Kelsy

[yslek]

bump

[Soph the vet]

I haven't used those but I'll tell you what works here. We have used Faber's Piano Adventures. My two oldest dc started with the traditional primer and both are now in level 2B. My dd5 began with Piano Adventures for the young beginner which comes with a CD and she has pretty much taught herself to play.