View Full Version : Stuart Little question
Renthead Mommy
03-14-2008, 07:52 PM
Okay we finished reading Stuart Little last night. Our copy is an old withdrawn school library copy. I'm confused by the ending. He's just still looking for the bird. Is there supposed to be more to the book? Is our copy funky as in it's part one and the rest is in another copy? Did White write this as a series? Is there supposed to be a SL 2? Or does it just end that way? (which I have to say is sort of disappointing)
Mrs Mungo
03-14-2008, 08:17 PM
Err...it's been quite a while since I've read it. My copy has 15 chapters, if you have the same that's probably it. Stuart Little was never my favorite, it feels so disjointed. It's almost like a collection of stories about a mouse instead of one long storyline.
abbeyej
03-14-2008, 08:25 PM
Your copy is fine. It's the style White chose for the book. Personally, if I ever read it aloud again, we're stopping a few chapters short of the ending and calling it a day.
Chris in VA
03-14-2008, 08:37 PM
ugg. I hated the ending of Stuart Little. It was completely disappointing, so no wonder you are looking for an alternative ending! lol
Charlotte's Web is tons, tons better.
kalanamak
03-14-2008, 09:12 PM
Okay we finished reading Stuart Little last night. Our copy is an old withdrawn school library copy. I'm confused by the ending. He's just still looking for the bird. Is there supposed to be more to the book? Is our copy funky as in it's part one and the rest is in another copy? Did White write this as a series? Is there supposed to be a SL 2? Or does it just end that way? (which I have to say is sort of disappointing)
To me, it was a little too sudden, but as for him still looking for the bird, well, such is life. I just wish there had been a little foreshadowing of it.
Renthead Mommy
03-14-2008, 09:58 PM
OKay, thank you all. I found where there had been SL 2, but it looked like it had been based on the movies. So that was also part of my confusion.
Boy, that was sort of a disappointing ending. We are going to read CW soon. That's one's better right? I've never actually read the book and the cartoon never really thrilled me as a kid (hence I never bothered with the book).
Thanks.
chickenpatty
03-14-2008, 10:19 PM
I am glad you asked this! We just finished listening to the audiobook and thought there was a cd missing.
Colleen
03-14-2008, 11:48 PM
Your copy is fine. It's the style White chose for the book. Personally, if I ever read it aloud again, we're stopping a few chapters short of the ending and calling it a day.
I just finished reading it aloud for what must have been the third time. It's never felt disappointing to me. I love that E.B. White didn't feel compelled to tie up the package with a pretty bow, but instead just let the story be...
Mama Lynx
03-15-2008, 12:27 AM
OKay, thank you all. I found where there had been SL 2, but it looked like it had been based on the movies. So that was also part of my confusion.
Boy, that was sort of a disappointing ending. We are going to read CW soon. That's one's better right? I've never actually read the book and the cartoon never really thrilled me as a kid (hence I never bothered with the book).
Thanks.
CW is a fantastic, fantastic, wonderful book. Promise!
Michelle T
03-15-2008, 12:31 AM
It leaves the ending up to the reader. Will he ever find the bird, or spend his life looking?
What I always wondered is why Mr. Little never questioned Mrs. Little a bit more extensively on how she happened to give birth to a mouse. :ohmy:
Michelle T
kalanamak
03-15-2008, 12:37 AM
It leaves the ending up to the reader. Will he ever find the bird, or spend his life looking?
What I always wondered is why Mr. Little never questioned Mrs. Little a bit more extensively on how she happened to give birth to a mouse. :ohmy:
Michelle T
A wise man knows when an answer may be displeasing or unsatisfactory to just not ask the question.
Michelle T
03-15-2008, 01:13 AM
A wise man knows when an answer may be displeasing or unsatisfactory to just not ask the question.
:smilielol5:
Michelle T
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2012, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.